Bloomberg: Iran’s Role In Israel Conflict Is Like Russian Nesting Doll
- 10.10.2023, 12:50
Tehran will have to face the consequences.
It has been as unsurprising as it is grotesque to see Iran’s leaders applaud Hamas’s “victory” even as evidence of atrocities against Israeli women and children mounts, Bloomberg writes.
From here on, the outlook becomes much more complicated for Tehran, but so too for Israel and the US.
“We still don’t know exactly what role Iran played in Saturday’s attack on Israel by Hamas, but there’s growing evidence that Tehran’s client at least asked permission, and that means Israeli and US policy makers will have to factor it into their responses,” stated in the material.
Iran is no longer as isolated or vulnerable as it once was. The war in Ukraine has shuffled geopolitical alignments and as a result, possibly for the first time since the 1979 revolution, Tehran can count on powerful friends to give it at least diplomatic protection. Its role in providing Moscow with attack drones for its invasion of Ukraine has ensured that.
The importance of Iran’s oil supply to suppressing prices on the global market, and its potential to disrupt much larger flows through the Strait of Hormuz also offer a measure of leverage, if not protection.
At the same time, as many have said already, the process of normalizing relations between Israel and the Arab world had been making progress since the 2020 US-brokered Abrahams accords. A deal adding Saudi Arabia was on the table, even as Israel embarked on a no-concessions policy in dealing with Palestinians living in Gaza and the West Bank. All that hit a wall on Saturday — a clear win for Iran.
The Hamas attack is precisely the kind of ostentatiously disruptive operation Iran has wanted to see for years, and offers a welcome distraction from its many internal problems.
For the Iranian regime, the main concern is that war with an enraged Israel, fully backed by the force of the US, could if miscarried be its last fight, or equally could mark the end of Hezbollah, its proxy force in Lebanon, says John Raine, a Middle East specialist and senior adviser for Geopolitical Due Diligence at the international Institute for Strategic Studies in London. That’s why Iran has in recent years tried to avoid a direct conventional war with either.
At the same time, the challenge for the US and Israel is punishing Iran without just expanding the coming conflict’s cost and destruction for themselves. Invading a nation of 88 million that’s cut through by mountains and more than 2.5 times the size of Ukraine isn’t an option. Strikes on the IRGC and its proxy forces outside Iran can have an impact, yet the Iranians need to present sufficient targets to be hit, and may not oblige. Air strikes within Iran could even do Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei a favor, prompting his domestic opponents to rally against a common foreign threat.
Relatively few ordinary Iranians would relish picking a fight with the US or Israel, but it’s worth remembering that Qassem Soleimani, the IRGC Al-Quds force head assassinated by the US in Iraq, in 2020, was one of the nation’s most popular figures. Even regime opponents backed the idea of fighting Sunni radicals such as Islamic State abroad, so they would not have to do so at home.
The pressure on both Israel and Iran to expand Operation Iron Sword against Hamas into a regional war is real. But a wider war is far from inevitable. Iran’s ultra-conservative leadership “will lionize Hamas as this fight goes on, but the time will come when it is under pressure to put its money where its mouth is, because Hamas will have its hat out there for help,’’ says Raine.
In Syria and Iraq, that meant sending IRGC personnel to the front lines, but the stakes in Gaza are much higher. Even Hamas, having made sure Israel would have to attack its stronghold in Gaza, can’t be sure if Iran’s aging Islamist revolutionaries will come to its rescue.