The Last Point Is Very Positive
- Vladimir Fesenko
- 20.11.2026, 14:30
The negotiating table became the symbol of the “meeting of the three” in Beijing.
And so, a meeting of the three leaders took place in Shenzhen. The hype surrounding it was enormous. This is likely why the Chinese side agreed to this meeting. As a result, attention to the APEC summit in China as a whole surged dramatically. Expectations for the meeting between the leaders of China, the U.S., and Russia were immense and mixed—if anything, they were cause for concern.
However, the results of this meeting—and even more so, its consequences—turned out to be quite limited. There was no division of the world or formation of a new world order. Incidentally, I wrote about this back in October, when all the hype was just beginning.
The main indicator of the meeting’s very modest results is the final document, grandly titled the “Declaration on Peace.” However, it’s rather strange to hear talk of peace from a country that has been waging a full-scale war against Ukraine for nearly five years. And the U.S. has been involved in two wars this year.
The Declaration contains only four brief points. The most specific of these concerns the three leaders’ shared negative stance toward the International Criminal Court (ICC). Apparently, they consider this to be the main international problem at the moment. However, despite this criticism, the ICC will not disappear, although its work will become more difficult. Incidentally, I would like to refute the widely held belief here that Russia was the driving force behind this point. It appears this was an initiative by Trump, who emphasized this topic in his opening remarks.
The first point calls for UN reform. However, I have never once heard the countries that are permanent members of the Security Council express a willingness to give up their permanent status on the UN Security Council or their veto power over any decisions made by that body. The aforementioned Declaration makes no mention of this either. And without this, it is hardly possible to speak of genuine UN reform.
Putin is effectively proposing to sell the end of the war
The second point calls for increasing the production and supply of petroleum products for the benefit of all countries of the world. This is certainly in the interest of China and the United States, which are suffering from high oil prices, while Russia is interested in increasing oil supplies to world markets, counting, in particular, on the lifting of sanctions against its oil.
The final point is very positive. It emphasizes that in a nuclear war, “there can be no victory, and it must not be waged.” As far as I know, the Chinese delegation insisted on this point. The three countries agreed to engage in dialogue on issues related to reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons. This wording represents a compromise, as the U.S. had sought more—namely, China’s participation in negotiations on limiting strategic offensive arms (specifically nuclear weapons and their delivery systems), which China, as expected, did not agree to. There is also no mention of the unacceptability of Iran’s nuclear program; instead, there is only vague language regarding the prevention of nuclear proliferation.
That’s all. Not a word about Ukraine. And this means that the three countries do not have a unified position regarding the Russian-Ukrainian war and the conditions for its conclusion. Perhaps this is even for the best. In any case, Russia failed to advance its position on this issue. And the impact of the “trilateral meeting” in Shenzhen on the negotiation process regarding the Russia-Ukraine war will be minimal and indirect. The bilateral meeting between Trump and Putin had a greater impact—and, it seems, not a particularly positive one.
The three leaders do not share a common position on most other important international issues either. Therefore, the conclusion is simple: they did not divide the world, nor did they define a new world order. And they could not have done so anyway. This isn’t 1945. And this wasn’t a meeting of victors. Of the three participants, only Xi appeared confident. Trump is already being viewed as a “lame duck” following the Republicans’ defeat in the U.S. congressional elections. Putin, meanwhile, appears to have merely “tagged along” with the two more influential leaders, even though it was Russia that had pushed for this meeting.
For me, the symbol of this meeting was the negotiating table at which the three leaders sat. The table was enormous, while the negotiators looked somewhat small in comparison. Moreover, the considerable physical distance between them symbolically demonstrated the significant differences in their political positions.
Vladimir Fesenko, Facebook